An oligarchy, in its purest sense, is a small group of people who control a much larger group, usually an organization, country, or society. The term is often confused with other forms of government, especially dictatorships and communism, neither of which fit the true definition of an oligarchy. As with all ruling types, there are pros and cons to this governing style, and examples highlight these characteristics.
The Term “Oligarch” Started With the Greeks
Ancient Greek philosopher and scientist Aristotle (c. 384 B.C. to 322 B.C.) coined the term “oligarkhes” to mean “the rule of the few.” Aristotle believed an oligarchy was a bad form of government because it led to ruling parties governing solely in their own interests, disregarding those interests of anyone outside their sphere, most often the voiceless poor.
About the Ruling Elite
In an oligarchy, those ruling may have gained their power due to their noble birth, wealth, family ties, religion, education, business interests, or military control. The group in charge are very close-knit; they are often unwilling to share their influence with any unrelated to them by birth, marriage, or status.
Pros of an Oligarchy
Oligarchies exist when an organization delegates power to a small group of people with knowledge and influence. This is not always a bad thing. Often, delegating power to a group of expert insiders is the only way for an organization to function. Another pro is that decisions made by an oligarchy are usually conservative since the goal is to preserve the status quo. This makes it less likely any single leader will steer society into risky ventures.
With a small group of people making the decisions, the rest of the organization can ignore the tedious work of governing. Instead, they can spend their time doing other things, such as focusing on their careers, improving their relationships, creating beautiful art, or inventing incredible things.
Cons of an Oligarchy
The negatives of an oligarchy far outweigh the positives. An oligarch often leads to an increase in income inequality. This is due to the leaders siphoning a majority of the society’s wealth for themselves leaving less for everyone else. For example, the salary of a corporate CEO is usually hundreds of times higher than most of his or her employees.
Oligarchies also run the risk of growing stale. The rulers choose members who share the same values and ideals. This lack of diversity leads to a decline in creativity and a loss of energy. A ruling party is a closed group uninterested in sharing their wealth and power. They keep the power they gain, making it near impossible for an outsider to break in. This often leads to a sense of hopelessness, and if people lose hope, they become frustrated and violent. This is when attempted, or successful overthrows of the ruling class occur, often resulting in a vacuum of power.
Reasons Why Oligarchies Form
- When leaders who are good at what they do agree to increase their power regardless of the benefit or detriment to the rest of the organization.
- A weak monarch or tyrant grants cronies power, thus enabling them to overthrow him and form their own oligarchy.
- If people in a democracy do not stay informed and involved, they may be willing to let those with the passion and knowledge to take charge.
Oligarchy Governments: Russia
To many outside of Russia, Vladimir Putin appears to be the leader, but in truth, he is part of an oligarchy that has ruled the country since the 1400s. In many oligarchies, the political leader, be it a president or a tzar, is beholden to the wealthy who fund the initiatives.
China and Saudi Arabia
- After the death of China’s dictator Mao Tse-Tung in 1976, an oligarchy was formed by the 103 members of the families descended from an elite group of Communist revolutionaries who helped found the People’s Republic of China in 1949. These descendants control the majority of the state-owned corporations. They collaborate with each other on business deals, and even marry into each other’s families.
- The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is not run by any one member of the royal family, making the country an oligarchy. The leader shares power with the descendants of King Abd al-Aziz al-Sa’ud, who founded the country and had 44 sons and 17 wives.
Is the United States Becoming an Oligarchy?
Economists predict that the U.S. is headed this way. One giant warning flag is the widening of the gap between rich and poor. Since 1979, the incomes of the top one percent of earners rose over 400 percent while that of the remaining 99 percent has stagnated. A recent study found policies favored by the richest ten percent of Americans pass more often than those of the poorest 50 percent. Essentially, if the rich oppose a policy, it is unlikely to pass, regardless of how many middle-class Americans favor it.